Fix: Windows 11 23H2 Window Size Issue

Hey guys! Facing issues with your window sizes not changing in Windows 11 23H2, especially when launching from a batch script? You're not alone! This article dives deep into this pesky problem, offering insights, potential solutions, and workarounds to get your window sizes back under control. We'll explore why this issue might be happening, how it differs from previous versions of Windows, and what you can do to fix it. Let's get started!

Understanding the Windows 11 23H2 Window Size Issue

So, what's the deal with window size changes in Windows 11 23H2? The core issue reported by users like tenox7 and cmdmax is that when launching applications or scripts from a batch file, the window size doesn't adjust as expected. Instead, only the window position and buffer might change, leaving the actual window dimensions stubbornly fixed. This behavior is a departure from how things worked in Windows 11 22H2 and earlier, where window size adjustments from batch scripts functioned correctly.

This problem particularly affects users who rely on batch scripts to automate tasks or configure their workspace, such as developers, system administrators, or anyone who prefers a customized computing environment. Imagine you have a script designed to open multiple command prompts at specific sizes and locations for a development project. If the window sizes are not changing as instructed, it can disrupt your workflow and make multitasking a real pain. The inconsistency—where the window size changes correctly when launched directly in the console but not from a script—adds another layer of frustration. This makes it harder to pinpoint the root cause and implement a consistent fix.

This change in behavior points to a potential regression or bug introduced in Windows 11 23H2. Regressions happen when a software update unintentionally breaks functionality that was working previously. Identifying the specific change that triggered this issue is crucial for Microsoft to address it effectively. The fact that this problem wasn't present in Windows 11 22H2 provides a clear starting point for investigation. It suggests that something within the update to 23H2 altered how window sizing commands are processed, especially when initiated from a batch script. For users who depend on consistent window behavior, understanding the technical details behind this issue is more than just academic; it's essential for maintaining their productivity and workflow.

Why Does This Happen? Potential Causes

Let's explore some potential reasons why Windows 11 23H2 is exhibiting this weird window size behavior. There are several areas we can investigate, ranging from changes in how the operating system handles window management to specific interactions with batch script execution.

One possibility is a change in the Windows window management system itself. Operating systems often undergo modifications to their core components to improve performance, security, or compatibility. If the underlying mechanisms for resizing windows were altered in 23H2, it could inadvertently affect how batch scripts interact with these functions. This might involve changes in the API calls used to set window sizes or how the system interprets requests from different processes.

Another potential factor is how batch scripts are executed in Windows 11 23H2. When you run a batch script, it's processed by the Command Interpreter (cmd.exe). If there have been changes to how cmd.exe handles commands related to window sizing, particularly when launched from a script, it could explain the discrepancy. This might include changes in process priority, how commands are parsed, or how the output is handled.

Security enhancements can also play a role. Operating system updates frequently include security measures designed to prevent malicious software from manipulating system processes. It's conceivable that a security update in 23H2 is interfering with the window sizing commands executed by batch scripts. This could be a case of overzealous security measures blocking legitimate actions, or it could be a sign of a more subtle conflict between the script's actions and the system's security policies.

Driver conflicts, though less likely in this specific scenario, are always a consideration. While window size issues are less directly related to graphics drivers than, say, display problems, it's still worth considering whether a recent driver update might be contributing to the problem. The interaction between the graphics subsystem and window management can sometimes produce unexpected results.

Finally, the issue could be a straight-up bug in Windows 11 23H2. Software bugs are inevitable, and sometimes they only surface under specific conditions or configurations. Given that the problem wasn't present in 22H2, it's reasonable to suspect that a new bug was introduced in the update to 23H2. Identifying and reporting such bugs is crucial for Microsoft to address them in future updates.

Troubleshooting Steps: How to Fix It

Alright, let's get down to the nitty-gritty and explore some troubleshooting steps to fix the window size issue in Windows 11 23H2. While a definitive solution might require a patch from Microsoft, there are several things you can try in the meantime.

First off, let's try running the batch script as an administrator. Sometimes, the issue arises because the script doesn't have the necessary permissions to modify window settings. Right-clicking on the batch file and selecting "Run as administrator" can often bypass this limitation. This ensures that the script has elevated privileges, which might be required to make changes to the window size.

Next, check the compatibility settings for both the batch script and the Command Prompt. Right-click on the batch file, go to "Properties," and then the "Compatibility" tab. Experiment with different compatibility modes, such as Windows 8 or Windows 10, to see if that resolves the issue. You can also try the "Run this program in compatibility mode for" option for cmd.exe itself. Compatibility settings can sometimes help older applications or scripts run correctly on newer operating systems by emulating the behavior of previous versions of Windows.

Review your batch script code. It's possible that there's an error in the script itself that's preventing the window size from changing correctly. Double-check the commands you're using to set the window size and ensure they are syntactically correct. Sometimes, a small typo or an incorrect parameter can lead to unexpected behavior. If you're using variables, make sure they are being set and used correctly.

Look into alternative methods for setting window size. Instead of relying solely on the commands within the batch script, you might explore using third-party utilities or scripting languages like PowerShell to achieve the desired result. PowerShell, for example, offers more advanced control over window management and might provide a workaround for the issue. These alternative methods may bypass the specific problem affecting batch scripts and provide a more reliable way to adjust window sizes.

If you suspect a recent update is the culprit, consider rolling back Windows 11 to a previous version (if feasible and if you know how). This is a more drastic step, but if the issue is severely impacting your workflow, it might be a temporary solution while waiting for a permanent fix. Rolling back involves uninstalling the latest updates or, in some cases, reverting to a previous build of Windows 11. However, remember to back up your data before attempting this, as it can sometimes lead to data loss.

Finally, ensure your system drivers are up to date, especially your graphics drivers. While less likely to be the direct cause, outdated drivers can sometimes lead to unexpected behavior. Visit the website of your graphics card manufacturer (e.g., NVIDIA, AMD, Intel) and download the latest drivers for your card. Keeping your drivers up to date is a good practice in general, as it can improve system stability and performance.

Potential Workarounds: Getting Your Windows Right

Okay, so the troubleshooting steps didn't completely fix the window size issue in Windows 11 23H2. Don't worry, we're not giving up! Let's explore some potential workarounds that might help you manage your window sizes until a permanent solution is available.

One workaround is to manually adjust the window size after the script has run. While not ideal, this can provide a quick fix in the short term. After the script launches the application, simply grab the window edges and resize them to your desired dimensions. It's a manual process, but it can help you get your windows arranged the way you need them.

Another option is to use a third-party window management tool. There are numerous utilities available that offer advanced features for arranging and resizing windows. These tools often provide more flexibility than the built-in Windows window management and can help you achieve a consistent window layout despite the issue. Some popular options include DisplayFusion, AquaSnap, and PowerToys (which includes a window management module called FancyZones). These tools allow you to define custom window layouts and quickly snap windows into place.

Consider using PowerShell instead of batch scripts for tasks that require window size adjustments. PowerShell is a more powerful scripting language that offers finer control over system processes, including window management. It might be able to bypass the issue affecting batch scripts and provide a more reliable way to set window sizes. PowerShell has cmdlets specifically designed for working with windows, such as Move-Window and Resize-Window, which can give you precise control over window positioning and dimensions.

Create a hybrid approach by combining batch scripts with PowerShell or other scripting languages. You could use a batch script to launch the application and then use a PowerShell script to adjust the window size. This allows you to leverage the strengths of both scripting environments and potentially circumvent the issue. For example, your batch script could call a PowerShell script that handles the window resizing.

Explore using virtual machines or compatibility mode for specific applications that require precise window sizing. If the issue is limited to certain programs, running them in a virtual machine or compatibility mode might provide a workaround. Virtual machines create an isolated environment where the application can run with its own set of settings, potentially avoiding the issue. Compatibility mode, as mentioned earlier, can also help older applications run correctly on newer operating systems.

Reporting the Issue: Help Microsoft Fix It

Guys, one of the most important things we can do is to report this Windows 11 23H2 window size issue to Microsoft. The more reports they receive, the more likely they are to investigate and fix the problem. Here's how you can do it:

Use the Feedback Hub app in Windows 11. This is the primary way to send feedback directly to Microsoft. Search for "Feedback Hub" in the Start menu, open the app, and click on "Add new feedback." Provide a detailed description of the issue, including the steps to reproduce it, and mention that it specifically affects Windows 11 23H2. The more detail you provide, the better. Include information like the specific commands you're using in your batch scripts, the applications affected, and any workarounds you've tried.

Participate in online forums and communities. Platforms like the Microsoft Community forums, Reddit, and other tech forums are great places to discuss the issue and share your experiences with others. By participating in these discussions, you can help raise awareness of the problem and potentially find additional solutions or workarounds. Microsoft employees often monitor these forums, so your input can be valuable.

Share your findings with other users. If you've discovered a workaround or a potential fix, share it with the community. This helps others who are experiencing the same issue and contributes to the collective knowledge base. Sharing your solutions can save others time and frustration, and it can also help Microsoft gather more information about the issue.

Keep your system updated. Make sure you have the latest Windows updates installed. Microsoft often releases bug fixes and improvements through Windows Update, so it's possible that a future update will address the window size issue. Regularly checking for and installing updates can help ensure you have the latest fixes.

By actively reporting the issue and engaging with the community, we can help Microsoft address this problem and ensure that Windows 11 23H2 works smoothly for everyone. Remember, your feedback matters!

Conclusion: Getting Those Windows in Order

So, we've taken a deep dive into the Windows 11 23H2 window size issue, exploring the problem, potential causes, troubleshooting steps, and workarounds. While it's frustrating to encounter such issues, remember that software is complex, and bugs happen. The key is to understand the problem, try different solutions, and report it to the developers.

Hopefully, the steps and workarounds we've discussed will help you manage your window sizes in Windows 11 23H2. And remember, by reporting the issue to Microsoft, you're contributing to making Windows a better operating system for everyone. Keep those windows in order, guys!